Ask Liz Weston

Get smart with your money

Liz Weston

Q&A: Roth conversions and holding periods

By

Dear Liz: Eight years ago I converted a number of stocks from an IRA to a Roth IRA and paid the taxes. Now I am in a position to convert the last shares but want to do it incrementally over the next four years. Does each conversion then require its own five-year waiting period or will anything in the existing Roth now qualify to be withdrawn at any time?

Answer: The IRS requires five-year holding periods before earnings can be withdrawn tax-free from Roth accounts. The five-year rule applies separately to each Roth conversion, so the partial conversions you’re contemplating will each have their own five-year holding period, says Mark Luscombe, principal analyst for Wolters Kluwer Tax & Accounting.

That’s different from regular Roth accounts, where the five-year rule starts the year the account was first opened and isn’t triggered again by subsequent contributions, Luscombe says.

Q&A: Credit cards and co-signers

By

Dear Liz: My son is in his mid-20s. He has a credit card that we co-signed and that has a credit limit he would likely not qualify for on his own. He would like to remove us as co-signers as he starts to take more personal control of his finances. Would it make more sense to apply for a new card using only his income information, and then slowly stop using the old card? Or is it better just to take the hit on his credit rating now and request our removal from the old card?

Answer: It’s not clear whether you’ll be able to bow out of this arrangement without closing the card. Most major credit card issuers don’t allow co-signers. More typically, parents would add their children as authorized users. While the parents can remove their children from the account, the opposite isn’t true.

If this is a co-signed card, the issuer may have an option for removing you. Your son will need to call and ask.

In general, though, it would be better for his credit to apply for a card on his own and leave this account open.

Q&A: Hard copies, thumb drives and the cloud: How to handle vital records when it’s time to flee

By

Dear Liz: We are assembling our important document to-go box with the typical things advised should we need to evacuate, such as birth and marriage certificates, passports, insurance documents, mortgage statements, etc. Many of the documents can be accessed online, so I wondered about pay-off statements from old loans and mortgages. Is it important to take copies of those? Also, what about grant deeds from previous properties that we no longer own?

Answer: In a disaster, you’ll need information to help you establish your identity and document what you currently own. Focus on safeguarding the most important paperwork and figure you can recreate the rest if necessary.

Start with documents that would be time-consuming or a hassle to replace, such as passports, birth and marriage certificates, immigration records, military records, vehicle titles, home inventories, appraisals, home plans or blueprints, recent tax returns and wills or other estate planning documents. The originals should be stored in a water- and fireproof place, such as a home safe or other secure location.

Consider storing copies of these documents, along with photos of your driver’s license and vehicle registration, on an encrypted thumb drive in your go bag or in a secure cloud-based storage service (Everplans is one option.) You could put physical copies in your evacuation bag, but much of the information could be helpful to an identity thief if stolen so you’ll have to weigh convenience against security.

Insurance policies are usually accessible online, but you may want to include your insurance companies’ contact information and policy numbers.

Also consider digitizing any family photos that aren’t already stored in the cloud. You may not have time to grab albums, and disaster victims often lament not having copied irreplaceable photos.

Q&A: Navigating the Risks of 401(k)s, IRAs, and Payable-on-Death Accounts

By

Dear Liz: You recently wrote about the drawbacks of payable on death accounts, including that the funds go directly to the beneficiaries before the estate’s expenses are paid. Aren’t all 401(k)s payable on death? I’m often reminded to update my beneficiary info whenever I log into my account. Should 401(k)s be converted to IRAs once we leave our jobs when we retire? At least one of my 401(k) accounts from a previous job is still in that company’s plan, as it is a very good plan. Can we designate that certain expenses be paid from the accounts before our beneficiaries receive their inheritance?

Answer: Retirement accounts, including 401(k)s and IRAs, typically have named beneficiaries that will inherit the money directly. That means retirement accounts have the same potential drawback as payable-on-death bank accounts or transfer-on-death arrangements. If you have no other assets when you die, the person who settles your estate may have to appeal to these beneficiaries to return some of the money to pay your final bills. The beneficiaries usually would be under no obligation to cooperate, however.

You could name your estate as your beneficiary, but that could have some tax drawbacks so you should consult an attorney before doing so.

Q&A: An aunt left him out of her will. Can his siblings share the windfall?

By

Dear Liz: My brother and I have received a cash inheritance from our aunt, as have our cousins, among a few others. Our youngest brother was excluded, as was our cousins’ youngest sibling. I believe my aunt, who was 96 when she died and in her 80s when her will was done, simply forgot these two as the family was spread out and contact was infrequent. My brother and I want to do the right thing for our younger brother and give him an equal share from our inheritance. I know most states don’t have inheritance taxes, but since he won’t technically be inheriting it I wonder if there are any other tax implications for us or him.

Answer: Whenever gift taxes are owed, which is rarely, they’re paid by the giver.

Dividing your inheritance with your brother would be a gift to him, so he would owe no taxes. You might have to file a gift tax return if the amount you give him is more than $19,000 (the current annual gift tax exclusion amount). But you wouldn’t owe gift taxes until the amount you give away over that annual limit exceeds your lifetime limit, which in 2025 is $13.99 million. The same is true for your other brother — a gift in excess of the $19,000-per-recipient annual exclusion would require filing a tax return, but probably not paying taxes.

Gifts in excess of the annual exclusion also reduce the amount you can pass free of estate taxes after your own death. If you’re a multimillionaire and likely to face these taxes, please consult an estate tax attorney.

Q&A: Medicare Advantage to Original Medicare

By

Dear Liz: I just read your answer about switching from Medicare Advantage plans to original Medicare, and how you might not be able to get an insurer to write you a supplemental Medigap plan. I was with a Medicare Advantage plan for years and then my medical group stopped participating. I have many preexisting conditions and would not be able to find adequate or affordable coverage if I had to apply for a supplemental plan. Luckily another insurer gave automatic acceptance to the 32,000 of us who were thrown out of our medical group so I was able to get full coverage through a Medicare supplement.

I hope you will repeat this info in several columns so consumers are better informed. I had no idea you couldn’t easily switch back and forth.

Answer: To recap, Medicare Advantage is the private insurance alternative to original Medicare. Like other private coverage, Medicare Advantage plans have networks and benefits that can change from year to year. Original Medicare benefits typically don’t change, but many expenses aren’t covered so you generally need a private insurance supplement to pay for those costs.

If you want to switch from Medicare Advantage to original Medicare after the first year, however, you normally don’t have “guaranteed issue” rights for a Medigap supplemental policy and you could pay a lot more for this important additional coverage.

There is a “nuclear option” that would give you guaranteed-issue rights again, and that’s moving out of your Medicare Advantage plan’s coverage area. You have to actually move, not just temporarily relocate. But you would be able to switch to original Medicare and get a guaranteed-issue supplemental plan.