• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Ask Liz Weston

Get smart with your money

  • About
  • Liz’s Books
  • Speaking
  • Disclosure
  • Contact

Medigap

Q&A: Medicare Advantage to Original Medicare

January 27, 2025 By Liz Weston

Dear Liz: I just read your answer about switching from Medicare Advantage plans to original Medicare, and how you might not be able to get an insurer to write you a supplemental Medigap plan. I was with a Medicare Advantage plan for years and then my medical group stopped participating. I have many preexisting conditions and would not be able to find adequate or affordable coverage if I had to apply for a supplemental plan. Luckily another insurer gave automatic acceptance to the 32,000 of us who were thrown out of our medical group so I was able to get full coverage through a Medicare supplement.

I hope you will repeat this info in several columns so consumers are better informed. I had no idea you couldn’t easily switch back and forth.

Answer: To recap, Medicare Advantage is the private insurance alternative to original Medicare. Like other private coverage, Medicare Advantage plans have networks and benefits that can change from year to year. Original Medicare benefits typically don’t change, but many expenses aren’t covered so you generally need a private insurance supplement to pay for those costs.

If you want to switch from Medicare Advantage to original Medicare after the first year, however, you normally don’t have “guaranteed issue” rights for a Medigap supplemental policy and you could pay a lot more for this important additional coverage.

There is a “nuclear option” that would give you guaranteed-issue rights again, and that’s moving out of your Medicare Advantage plan’s coverage area. You have to actually move, not just temporarily relocate. But you would be able to switch to original Medicare and get a guaranteed-issue supplemental plan.

Filed Under: Medicare, Q&A Tagged With: Medicare, Medicare Advantage, Medicare Advantage plan, Medicare supplement insurance plans, Medicare supplemental plan, Medigap

Q&A: Be aware of these issues when switching between Medicare Advantage and Medicare

January 7, 2025 By Liz Weston

Dear Liz: I am planning to retire this year. If I choose a Medicare Advantage Plan, am I able to switch back to original Medicare without paying a fine?

Answer: Medicare won’t charge you extra, but you won’t necessarily have “guaranteed issue” rights for a Medigap supplemental policy. If you want to switch after the first 12 months, you could pay a lot more for this important supplemental coverage.

To recap, Medicare Advantage plans are the all-in-one alternative to original Medicare.

Medicare Advantage plans may offer types of coverage that original Medicare does not, such as hearing, dental or eye care. Many people like the fact that their Advantage plans seem to include more than original Medicare, and do so for a low or even no additional monthly premium.

But Medicare Advantage plans are offered by private insurers, which typically have networks of medical providers. These networks, as well as other benefits, can change from year to year. If you get care outside the networks, you typically pay more — sometimes a lot more. The rap on Medicare Advantage plans is that they can be great when you’re healthy, but depending on the plan may not be so great if you get sick.

With original Medicare, benefits remain the same and you can use any provider that accepts Medicare (the vast majority do). But original Medicare coverage has significant gaps, which is why you’ll need a Medigap plan offered by a private insurer.

If you opt for original Medicare when you are first eligible, insurers are required to issue you a Medigap policy and can’t charge you more based on your health status. Without guaranteed issue, an insurer can refuse to write you a Medigap policy or charge you a lot more.

You also have guaranteed issue rights if you buy a Medicare Advantage plan when you first become eligible for Medicare, but decide within 12 months to switch to original Medicare.

Filed Under: Medicare Tagged With: health insurance, Medicare, Medicare Advantage, Medicare supplement insurance plans, Medigap

This week’s money news

October 30, 2023 By Liz Weston

This week’s top story: Watch for these 3 Medigap shopping surprises to avoid overpaying. In other news: What home buyers should know as mortgage rates top 8%, cut EV costs with electric company incentives, and what to buy on Black Friday and Cyber Monday 2023.

Watch for These 3 Medigap Shopping Surprises to Avoid Overpaying
Medicare beneficiaries should watch for shopping surprises when choosing a Medigap plan to avoid paying too much for coverage.

As Mortgage Rates Top 8%, What Home Buyers Should Know
Interest rates on 30-year fixed-rate home loans have reached a milestone not seen for over two decades. What does that mean for this housing market?

Cut EV Costs With Electric Company Incentives
Electricity providers offer a range of EV rebates, from vehicle purchase to charging station installation.

What to Buy (and Skip) on Black Friday and Cyber Monday 2023
Retailers like Amazon, Target and Walmart pushed October sales as an early start to the holiday shopping season again this year.

Filed Under: Liz's Blog Tagged With: Black Friday 2023, Cyber Monday 2023, Electric company incentives, EV, Medicare, Medigap, Mortgage rates 2023

Q&A: What you should know about Medicare, Medigap and Advantage plans

October 4, 2021 By Liz Weston

Dear Liz: I’ve read your most recent columns about Medicare Advantage and believe that more should be said before people decide to go that route.

You mentioned that switching from Medicare Advantage to Medicare itself can be problematic. As a couple who have had both plans and now have Medicare with a Medigap plan, I want to say that the best (and, by the way, easiest) switch my husband and I made was to go back to Medicare.

People should understand that Medicare Advantage plans become their primary insurance, severely limiting their ability to go to whatever doctor or hospital is most convenient. When traveling, they are limited to the hospital and doctor they chose with their Advantage plan, the one near home! My husband also could not go to a doctor I had because we were signed up at different local hospitals.

So I phoned Medicare in 2009 and a young man was so helpful, and in no time we were back on Medicare. He said to go to the Medicare website, choose from the many Medigap options offered that suited our needs, and we did. It was that easy.

We opted for no copays, skilled nursing care, and much more. Granted, our monthly premiums are more than they would have been before, but since that date we have not laid out one cent for medical care including doctor visits, my husband’s open heart surgery (at a hospital of our choosing), emergency room and surgery for my broken ankle, and annual EKGs to monitor his heart.

Surprisingly, we also have coverage for foreign medical treatments and took advantage of that in 2018 for minor surgery needed. The Medigap insurance covered 80% of that when our travel insurer refused to pay.

Our Medigap policy also allows us to go to any doctor or hospital without a referral. And, of course, Medicare is accepted throughout the U.S., and Medicare Advantage plans are not. The tens of thousands of dollars we have saved in the last 11 years make it worth paying more each month, and we have peace of mind.

Answer: Thanks for writing and for sharing your experience.

For readers who haven’t kept up with the discussion: Medicare Advantage plans are offered by private insurers as an all-in-one alternative to traditional Medicare, the government-administered health insurance program for people 65 and older. Medicare Advantage plans typically cover some things that Medicare does not, such as vision, dental and hearing care, but the plans also have regional networks of providers you’re expected to use. You’ll pay more, and sometimes all, of the bill if you use out-of-network providers.

Traditional Medicare allows you to go to any doctor or hospital that accepts Medicare — which includes the vast majority of both — but can have substantial copays and other cost-sharing. A supplemental plan or Medigap plan offered by a private insurer can cover those costs, and most Medigap plans also offer emergency coverage abroad.

The premiums for Medicare plus Medigap can be higher than those for Medicare Advantage plans, but ultimately may prove more cost-effective for people who travel frequently or who want more choice about their care.

If you sign up for a Medigap plan when you first enroll in Medicare, the insurer is required to take you. If you miss that open enrollment period, an insurer can charge you more or even deny you coverage because of preexisting conditions.

There are a few exceptions, however. If you initially enrolled in a Medicare Advantage plan but want to switch to Medicare plus a Medigap plan within the first 12 months, you’re allowed to get a Medigap policy without underwriting.

Filed Under: Health Insurance, Q&A Tagged With: Medicare, Medicare Advantage, Medigap, q&a

Wednesday’s need-to-know money news

July 8, 2020 By Liz Weston

Today’s top story: Why missing college this fall is a bad idea. Also in the news: Why you should get your finances in top shape now to refi your student loans, choosing the Medigap plan that’s right for you, and how to apply for a $1,000 grant if you’re a freelancer or gig economy worker.

Why Missing College This Fall Is a Bad Idea
You could be wasting time and money.

Get your finances in top shape now to refi your student loans
Get the best deal possible when the grace period ends.

‘Medigap’ insurance covers some Medicare costs. How to choose a plan that’s right for you
Covering some of your Medicare costs.

How to Apply for a $1,000 Grant if You’re a Freelancer or Gig Economy Worker
Apply for an EIDL.

Filed Under: Liz's Blog Tagged With: college, Coronavirus, freelancers, gap year, gig workers, Medicare, Medigap, Student Loans

Primary Sidebar

Search

Copyright © 2025 · Ask Liz Weston 2.0 On Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in