Dear Liz: Regarding the inherited gold coins question, why would anybody tell the IRS they inherited coins and subject themselves to a 28% capital gains tax? That seems very illogical.
Answer: To clarify, the original reader was asking about selling gold coins which had risen dramatically in value since she inherited them. Coins are considered collectibles so the difference between the inherited value and the sale price would be subject to a 28% federal capital gains tax.
How would the IRS know if you’ve sold gold coins for a profit? A dealer who buys the coins might be required to file a form with the IRS that’s designed to thwart money laundering. Also, payments are typically made through bank transfers or checks, unless you’re planning to walk out with a bag of cash like a cartoon bank robber. Bank transactions could be examined if you’re ever audited.
Even if you calculate the odds of getting caught as low, the question remains: Do you only do the right and lawful thing when you have to?
Most people who aren’t sociopaths have a sense of integrity. Doing something they know to be wrong damages that integrity, even if no one else ever knows. You may be able to save a bit of money by cheating on your taxes, but you can’t put a price on a clear conscience.