• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Ask Liz Weston

Get smart with your money

  • About
  • Liz’s Books
  • Speaking
  • Disclosure
  • Contact

Advisors to women: Don’t quit

March 11, 2014 By Liz Weston

Zemanta Related Posts ThumbnailWomen with young children often discover that child care costs eat up much of what they earn. If they’re married to a big earner in a high tax bracket, they could lose most of the rest of their wages to high marginal tax rates.

But advising them to quit working is short sighted, two Certified Financial Planners suggest in the most recent issue of the Journal of Financial Planning.

Jerry A. Miccolis and Marina Goodman note in “Advising Married Women on Investing–in Themselves” (may be restricted to FPA member access only) that child care costs usually drop when the kids enter school while the mother’s income typically rises over time. Stopping out, meanwhile, often leads to lower lifetime earnings. The authors suggest women view those early years, when they’re working for not much financial gain, as an investment in their future–sort of an extended internship, if you will. They write:

“[W]ork experience leads to career advancement, which could have a quantum-level impact on her financial future. Say a woman spends five years working while getting no financial benefit due to taxes and child care costs. Her youngest then enters school and suddenly child care costs plummet. After five years of experience, she may get promoted and now her income may be $75,000. If, instead, she was just starting out at that point, she would be earning $50,000. (We’re ignoring inflation in this simple example—it would, of course, merely magnify the effects.) The difference is not $25,000. It is more like being an entire professional level higher for the next 30 years. Over the course of a career it can be the difference between middle management and eventually being in the C-suite.”

The authors note that “A woman’s ability to earn a decent salary is the most comprehensive insurance policy she can have.” Staying employed, even part time, and keeping up any professional credentials can help her family if her partner loses a job, becomes disabled or suffers a business setback. It can also be an insurance policy for her in the far greater risk of divorce:

“Even among upper-income families, many women would still experience a significant decline in lifestyle upon divorce, especially if they have no means of supporting themselves. The risk that a woman will get divorced is greater than the sum of the risks of her husband’s premature death, disability, or just about any other financial catastrophe all put together.”

This information may be most relevant for the kinds of women financial planners are most likely to advise: college-educated women with careers, rather than jobs. The price for stopping out may be less if you’re in a low-wage, low-skilled job rather than one where significant financial advances are possible. But any parent contemplating time away from work should be looking at the longer term financial picture, and those who choose to stay home should make sure they have significant savings to help offset their greater financial vulnerability.

Related Posts

  • What good financial advice looks like

    Good financial advice can help you achieve your life goals. Bad financial advice can cost…

  • How to quit stalling and write your will

    You know you should have a will, but you keep stalling. No one likes to…

  • Q&A: Finding fee-only financial planners

    Dear Liz: Every so often your column mentions an organization that lists financial planners that…

  • Q&A: Finding affordable financial planning

    Dear Liz: I’ve read your advice and that of many others to only use a…

Filed Under: Liz's Blog Tagged With: financial advice, Kids, parenting, women and money

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Matt R says

    March 12, 2014 at 1:59 pm

    This is good advice from a financial perspective, but a couple facing the decision about whether or not to keep one parent home needs to think about less tangible issues as well. The stress of having a family with two employed parents, the lack of time spent with children when they are very small, and the temptation to live on both incomes are also issues to think about.

    A bigger bank account isn’t such a great thing when you’re not having sex because your both too tired or you’re fighting over who should stay home from work when a kid is sick.

    • Liz Weston says

      March 13, 2014 at 3:40 pm

      There are definitely a lot of things to consider. This is mostly a counterpoint to those who are just looking at the short-term financial impact.

Primary Sidebar

Search

Copyright © 2025 · Ask Liz Weston 2.0 On Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in