• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Ask Liz Weston

Get smart with your money

  • About
  • Liz’s Books
  • Speaking
  • Disclosure
  • Contact

Q&A: Windfall elimination provision explained

November 22, 2021 By Liz Weston

Dear Liz: I understand your explanation of the windfall elimination provision that reduces Social Security benefits if someone is receiving a pension from a job that didn’t pay into Social Security. I am a teacher with such a pension who also worked more than 10 years in the private sector. I’d accept the explanation and the reduction if the WEP were applied in all 50 states. As you know, it is not. How is this reduction justifiable in any way?

Answer: The idea that WEP doesn’t apply in all states is a myth. WEP applies regardless of where you live. What matters is whether you’re getting a pension from a job that didn’t pay into Social Security. Some states provide such pensions while others don’t.

“If a state doesn’t provide its workers with their own pension and instead has them join Social Security, then exempting them from the windfall elimination provision is fully appropriate,” says economist Laurence Kotlikoff, president of Economic Security Planning Inc., which offers Social Security claiming software at MaximizeMySocialSecurity.com.

As mentioned earlier, WEP is not designed to take away from you a benefit that others get. Rather, the provision is designed to keep those who receive pensions from jobs that didn’t pay into Social Security from getting significantly higher benefits than workers who paid into the system their entire working lives.

That can happen because of the progressive nature of Social Security benefits, which are meant to replace a higher percentage of a lower-earner’s income than that of a higher earner.

People who don’t pay into the system for many years can appear to be much lower earners than they actually are. Without adjustments, they would get bigger benefit checks than people in the private sector with the same income who paid much more in Social Security taxes.

Related Posts

  • Q&A: Social Security windfall elimination provision

    Dear Liz: You've written about the windfall elimination provision, which reduces the Social Security checks…

  • Q&A: Social Security windfall elimination provision

    Dear Liz: I was referred to an answer you wrote in 2017 explaining Social Security’s…

  • Q&A: Triggering the windfall elimination provision

    Dear Liz: After working and paying into Social Security for more than 40 years, I…

  • Q&A: Windfall elimination provision

    Dear Liz: I just read your answer regarding the windfall elimination provision question. I receive a pension after…

Filed Under: Social Security Tagged With: q&a, Social Security, windfall elimination provision

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Richard Wilbur says

    November 27, 2021 at 9:24 am

    If you worked for a State Pension and didn’t contribute to social security I understand no Social Security. But earning that State Pension and working a second job that you pay into social security and earn ssn benefits but later being penalized by having your earned ssn benefits lowered because you also earned a State Pension IS NOT fair using the WEP.

Primary Sidebar

Search

Copyright © 2025 · Ask Liz Weston 2.0 On Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in