Q&A: Financial advice and family

Dear Liz: Regarding the brother who has the financially irresponsible sisters, in general I agree with you about not pestering people who don’t want advice. But with family, it’s different. It is quite obvious to me and other readers that this man is concerned about his sisters coming to him later in life even if he didn’t state that in his letter. Telling them he won’t help when they come to him later in life (and they will) isn’t realistic. Maybe his continual pestering will finally make them come to their senses.

Answer: If you’ve had any problems in your own life — you needed to lose a few pounds, say, or stop smoking — think about how you would have received the “continual pestering” of a sibling on the issue.

Announcing to his sisters that he won’t help them financially before they ask may have an unintended side effect. If Mom has any money left when she dies, she may well allocate more of it to the sisters under the assumption that they’ll “need” it more because their mean old brother won’t help them.

Related Posts

  • Q&A: Unsolicited financial advice Dear Liz: Your answer to the financially savvy brother whose advice is lost on his sisters was a bit harsh and shortsighted, so my guess […]
  • Q&A: Why credit scores drop suddenly Dear Liz: The same thing happened to me as to the person in your column whose credit score dropped more than 100 points after large […]
  • Q&A: HELOC situation improves Dear Liz: Your recommendation that a retired couple consider a home equity line of credit to pay for home repairs astonished me. According […]
  • Q&A: Adding sister to a house deed Dear Liz: A reader recently asked about giving a rental house to the sister that has been living in it for 10 years. You mentioned that […]